--- Nettie Baugher, sr., Biglerville: Although she was the No. 2 player on her team, Baugher placed fifth in the YAIAA Class AA Singles Championship and finished with 10 wins. She also posted a 9-2 record with three different doubles partners.
--- Mackenzie Bortner, sr., South Western: Earning her third first-team nod, Bortner posted 11 singles wins and placed fourth in the YAIAA Class AAA Singles Championship. She and partner Madison Bortner also took fourth in the YAIAA Class AAA Doubles Championship.
--- Carlee Brumgard, jr., Biglerville: A three-time All-Area Player of the Year, Brumgard posted a 16-3 singles mark and placed second in both the YAIAA Class AA Singles Championship and, with partner Jenna Glass, the YAIAA Class AA Doubles Championship. That pair also took fourth in the District 3 Class AA Doubles Championship.
--- Laney Jenkins, sr., Hanover: Returning to the first team after a year's absence, Jenkins was the shining light on a rebuilding Hawkette program. She posted a 9-8 singles record and placed fourth in the YAIAA Class AA Singles Championship. She also had a role in all five doubles wins by the Hawkettes this season.
--- Sarah Rudasill, sr., New Oxford: Another three-time All-Area first-team selection, Rudasill was a solid No. 1 performer for the Colonials, enabling New Oxford post a .500 season. She won 10 singles matches and combined with Emily Groft to produce five doubles triumphs.
--- Morgan Anthony, sr., Bermudian Springs
--- Madison Bortner, fr., South Western
--- Amanda Craver, jr., Spring Grove
--- Jenna Glass, soph., Biglerville
--- Bryn Yurick, jr., Bermudian Springs